• Post author:
  • Post last modified:January 2, 2022
  • Post category:Sleep

As an excited new mom, you would have come across innumerable collections of the best baby crib mattress. Which product to rely on seems to be a challenging task? The price tags vary with the quality and the extra features implemented in the product.

While selecting the mattress for your loved ones ensure there are no compromises on the quality factors. Now, it is high time to analyze the extended features in every product and choose depending on your needs.

You may also like:

Our top picksProductsRating
Best Innerspring MattressesKolcraft Waterproof Toddler & Baby Crib Mattress4.7
Best Foam crib MattressesGraco Premium Foam Crib and Toddler Mattress in a Box4.9
Best Double-sided MattressesColgate Mattress 2-Stage Baby & Toddler Mattress4.9
Best Organic Crib MattressNaturepedic Organic Crib Mattress4.8
Best Mini Crib Mattress Moonlight Slumber Dual Sleep Surface 5″ Mini Crib Mattress4.5
Best Waterproof Crib Mattress PadPlushDeluxe Crib Mattress Protector4.8
Best Non-toxic Crib MattressMilliard Hypoallergenic Baby Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed Mattress4.8
Best Breathable Crib MattressNewton Baby Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed5.0
Best Affordable Crib MattressSafety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Crib & Toddler Bed Mattress4.6

Types of Baby Crib Mattresses

There are three types of mattress to support the daily needs of your innocent souls. You can choose the perfect fit which meets your requirements without any compromises.

  • Innerspring Mattress

It is the traditional best crib mattress for babies, just born infants, and toddlers.

In this model, the mattress comprises of steel coils and loaded with cushioning material like Polyester, Cotton and Foam etc.

The products of Innerspring Mattress vary with the number of steel coils arranged along with the quantity of cushioning material available.

  • Foam Mattress

Here, in this model, the mattress is made up of Polyurethane, foam resin etc.

It is the best budget crib mattress. You must press the Foam mattress and find out how long it takes to regain the shape.

The faster shape regain seems to be the quality product.

  • Double-sided Mattress

It is an expensive mattress. You can use this mattress in two ways.

One side of the mattress is firm enough to hold your infants optimally.

The other side if soft and suits well for the toddlers.


Amazon Baby Registry

  • This Transaction Is Valid For Anyone Who Wants It (Single, Twins, Triplets, Etc.)
  • Click Here To Launch Your Amazon Baby Registry
  • Get A $35 Surprise Package For Parents And Babies

What Is The Best Baby Crib Mattress?

1. Best Innerspring Mattresses: Kolcraft Waterproof Toddler & Baby Crib Mattress


Why we love it?

It is the best waterproof crib mattress pad. This mattress is easy to clean. It resists stains, moisture etc. It is enough if you wipe it out with dump cloth to clean the mattress surface.

There are 150 steel coils to enhance the firmness of the product.

Keep in mind

Some of the users feel that the life span of this product seems to be very short when compared to other mattresses in the market.

Another Mom’s opinion

Heather comments that ‘Comfortably firm mattress, perfect for newborn and toddler. The “wipe clean” material isn’t loud and crinkly like most mattresses with similar cover. It fit our infant crib snuggly, perfect for safe sleep conditions. If you are looking for high quality, yet affordable, infant or toddler mattress, I would highly recommend this!’.

Additional facts

It has a ‘Green Guard Gold’ certified for its low chemical content during the manufacturing process.

2. Best Foam crib Mattresses: Graco Premium Foam Crib and Toddler Mattress in a Box

Graco Premium Foam Crib

Why we love it?

You can easily roll it and fit compactly during travel. It can be compressed into a lightweight box, which is highly portable.

This mattress has high-quality foam compilation to ensure airflow within the mattress. It is a waterproof product and the outer cover is removable for easy wash.

Keep in mind

Few Mom’s feel that the chemical smell survives on this mattress up to 3 days. In certain piece the chemical smell remains forever.

Another Mom’s opinion

Gaby states that ‘Excellent measure for your baby and up to 6 years old for cribs that are made bed. Good texture waterproof lining with washing machine. It inflates to the maximum in almost an hour! Slightly stiff but very good quality looks sturdy’. 

Additional facts

This product meets all the standards and regulatory instructions from ASTM, CPSC safety standards, Federal Flammability standards, etc. It comes with a limited warranty for up to 6 years.

3. Best Double-sided Mattresses: Colgate Mattress 2-Stage Baby & Toddler Mattress


Why we love it?

It suits the babies and toddlers as a two-in-one mattress. It is the best product to use in the long run. This mattress is an ultra-soft and organic product.

This mattress is designed and manufactured under the guidance of a specialist for over 65 years.

In this product, there are multiple dimensions and while purchasing make sure you are aware of your crib’s length and width parameters.

Keep in mind

The rigidness of this product seems to be very high and it feels like a rock for infants.

Another Mom’s opinion

Trixin comments that ‘will keep a close eye on mattress each week when we change sheets but we have seen no problems. Our mattress doesn’t get wet often and no issues with it coming apart. Will update if we have any changes!’.

Additional facts

It is a certified mattress by various regulatory bodies worldwide like Green Guard Gold certified, CertiPUR- US certified etc.

4. Best Organic Crib Mattress: Naturepedic Organic Crib Mattress

Naturepedic Organic Crib Mattress

Why we love it?

It is completely an organic product and contains non-toxic materials. Easy to clean through simple wipes using soap and water.

Lightweight mattress and it has two levels of firmness to suit babies and toddlers.

Another Mom’s opinion

Annie reviews that ‘It is a firm bed mattress. After two years of daily use, it is the same firmness. I love it. Non-toxic and waterproof, it is a great investment. It is a peace of mind.’. 

Additional facts

This product is available in standard sizes and certified by GOTS and Green Guard. It contains organic cotton and non-toxic fabric.

5. Best Mini Crib Mattress: Moonlight Slumber Dual Sleep Surface 5″ Mini Crib Mattress

Moonlight Mini Crib Mattress

Why we love it?

There is no stitches on the mattress surface and thereby easy to wipe. It is ready for your baby’s nap and no need for any fitted sheet.

There are layers of foam to provide effective firmness surface for the baby to rest comfortably.

Keep in mind

This mattress does not fit properly with the mini crib.

Another Mom’s opinion

Addy Scout conveys her review as ‘this mattress was exactly what I was looking for 4 months after replacing multiple foam pads for my baby he was under 1 year old. it’s a shame that the mini crib did not work out for him in the end because he moves too much in his sleep that it gets stuck but otherwise the mattress was perfect.’.

Additional facts

It has a lifetime warranty for manufacturer’s defects. It is certified by Greengurad gold and CertiPUR-US

6. Best Waterproof Crib Mattress Pad: PlushDeluxe Crib Mattress Protector


Why we love it?

The bamboo quilted mattress seems to be extraordinary and provide great comforts to your baby. Moreover, there is no rustle type of noise when your baby moves amidst sound sleep.

Keep in mind

This product is free from harmful chemicals like Vinyl, BPA, phthalate, latex, lead, flame retardants.

Another Mom’s opinion

Amaoge from the US talks about this product as ‘It was great to see. I was impressed. Again I am not sure how it will hold up to bodily fluids. Overall, the pad cover is very soft with no packing smell’.

Additional facts

It has an advanced breathable membrane and allows sufficient airflow to provide a comfortable sound sleep for your baby.

7. Best Non-toxic Crib Mattress: Milliard Hypoallergenic Baby Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed Mattress


Why we love it?

Highly dense compact product and it will not lose its shape. The unique firmness suits the babies and toddlers optimally. This mattress excites the users with perfect dimension and great comforts

Keep in mind

It is a non-toxic crib mattress and 100% waterproof. It has a standard size to fit appropriately with the baby’s crib and toddler’s bed.

Another Mom’s opinion

Travis says that ‘We bought this mattress for my daughter when she transitioned to her toddler bed and again 4 years later for my son. This is a great company with excellent customer service. We had an issue with the first mattress we bought and it was fixed right away. This is waterproof and very comfortable.’

Additional facts

This mattress meets the Federal anti-flammability standards thereby employing non-toxic materials during the manufacturing process.

8. Best Breathable Crib Mattress: Newton Baby Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed

Newton Baby Crib Mattress

Why we love it?

Your baby takes a sound sleep for long hours comfortably because this mattress regulates temperature aptly. It prevents overheating and sweaty backs.

Keep in mind

It is a Hypoallergic product and is designed exclusively for babies and toddlers. This mattress takes the title and winner of numerous awards worldwide.

Another Mom’s opinion

Hillary starts with a comment line ‘Peace of Mind’ and add on with supporting words such as ‘This gave us peace of mind. Our baby is a tummy sleeper and does not care that there is a “Back to Sleep” campaign. We got this mattress because of the design. It’s like a big plastic loofa and you can breathe through it easily without restriction’.

Additional facts

Easy to wash and certified by GreenGuard Gold for lower emission.

It is 100% recyclable and doesn’t contain foam, allergens, latex, or springs.

9. Best Affordable Crib Mattress: Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Crib & Toddler Bed Mattress

Safety 1st Crib Bed Mattress

Why we love it?

It provides firm support with the help of thermo-bonded fiber. The Vinyl outer cover assists the new moms for easy cleaning.

Keep in mind

The size is standard and fits perfectly in the regular baby’s crib. It is America’s most recommended mattress for the newborns.

Another Mom’s opinion

Trixin comments that ‘will keep a close eye on mattress each week when we change sheets but we have seen no problems. Our mattress doesn’t get wet often and no issues with it coming apart. Will update if we have any changes!’.

Additional facts

It has a 10-year limited warranty period.

This product has a prestigious certification for its low chemical emission feature from GreenGuard Gold.

Crib Mattress Safety Guidelines

  • Quality Mattress

It is highly advisable to purchase a quality product and avoid second-hand goods. Always choose a fresh piece to overcome unnecessary health issues of your loved ones.

  • No more blankets in a mattress

Do not use any pillows or blankets in the crib mattress. It might cover your baby’s face thereby leading to suffocation problems. So, keep the crib mattress empty.

  • Proper position

Always rest your baby on the back because it is the safest position for your dear one to take a deep sleep. It reduces the risk of SIDS (Sudden Infant Death Syndrome). It occurs during the first year of the baby.

  • Flip the mattress

There is a double mattress in the market where you can use one side for babies and the other side for toddlers. Before you flip the mattress, you must consult your pediatrician to check whether it is the right time to turn the mattress.

Features to Consider in Good Crib Mattresses

You bear ample responsibilities despite the excitement of being a new parent for your loved ones. The first task you will face as a new mom is choosing the right mattress for your dear baby. Look for the below features while selecting the appropriate product from the commercial store.

  • Comfortable and theme-based: Make sure the mattress attracts your newborn because it is the place where your baby spends a lot of time at this phase of life. It is highly advisable to purchase a theme-based mattress to create a lively place for your baby.
  • Perfect Size: Measure the length and width of the mattress exactly to fit perfectly within the crib. You must ensure the mattress is comfortable for your baby during the sound sleep. Size plays a vital part when selecting the best mattress.
  • Go Green: There is a wide range of best organic crib mattress are available for sales in many stores worldwide. You can choose the organic ones as it is free from harmful chemical residues on the finished products.
  • Two-sided mattress: If you have any plans to use the mattress in the long run then go for two-in-one models which suits the babies and toddlers. The firm side of the mattress fits your baby needs and as he/she grows you can use the other softer side of the product.
  • Air Circulation: You must select a mattress which permits enough airflow throughout the baby’s body. An optimum air circulation protects the baby from unwanted irritations and he/she will feel comfortable to spend many hours without any issues.


Thus, it is high time to end the discussion on the best crib mattress. Choose the perfect mattress which meets your expectations without any compromises.

Every product is unique and comprises remarkable features. Go for the right fit because it is the space where your baby spends a lot of time. Take sufficient time to analyze the product and finally decide on the quality mattress. Surf through the above products keenly and purchase the best fit for your needs.

How We Got These Results

After a survey of thousands of moms and dads who are a part of the mommies buy community, we have found out what are their favorite products for their babies. Besides, we asked them to give their feedback on certain products.

Based on their reviews or feedback, we have listed out these top products that the parents love buying. We have also done enough research in addition to parents’ feedback to create this article. We know that babies deserve the best, that is why we made this effort.

As customers purchase these products through the links in this article, note that our community may receive a commission, but these are Mommies Buy community’s top choices.

>>> Check here to read more posts about baby sleep.

Latest posts by Susan (see all)

Leave a Reply