Are you searching for a baby keepsake box? Then, you are in the right place because we will list out the top 5 best keepsake boxes that you should consider buying.

We know that because of the large number of products available in the market, it can be quite tricky for you to find the right keepsake box for your needs. So, read further to find out in detail.

Editor’s PickProductRating
Best PersonalizedSavor Baby Keepsake Box4.8
Best for TeethCampTek Baby Tooth Box and Tooth Holder4.9
Best Wooden BoxDust and Things Personalized Baby Keepsake Box5.0
Best for Baby Boy Robert Frederick Large Collapsible Memory Storage Box4.6
Best for Baby Girl Baby Milestone Keepsake Storage Box4.7

What Do you Put in a Baby Keepsake Box? –Baby Keepsakes Moms Cherish Most

As a parent, you know that the first year of your baby’s life is most precious.

It is really an extraordinary experience to see your little baby grow in front of your eyes. The rapid development-mental and physical makes the baby’s first year so amazing and special.

Then, the day your toddler enters grade school is also one of the most memorable days. As a mom, you want to preserve some of the precious items which you can cherish for years to come.

From the first diaper to birthday newspapers, here are some mementos other moms are very glad to have kept.


Amazon Baby Registry

  • This Transaction Is Valid For Anyone Who Wants It (Single, Twins, Triplets, Etc.)
  • Click Here To Launch Your Amazon Baby Registry
  • Get A $35 Surprise Package For Parents And Babies

How to DIY Baby Memory Box

Here is what our daughter’s keepsake box includes:

  • Her first outfit and favorite blankie
  • A few of her favorite books
  • A letter her daddy and I wrote her
  • Her favorite stuffed animal
  • First shoes — they’re just so tiny I had to keep them for her!
  • A keepsake box to put all these memories together!

More ideas you can try:

  • First ultrasounds
  • Hospital Blanket
  • Hand Print and Foot print at birth
  • First holiday/birthday outfit(s)
  • Cards from birth and first birthday
  • Letters from mommy, daddy, grandparents, etc.
  • Favorite books, so they can read them to their own kids one day
  • First haircut( before and after pictures), first hair bow and first tie
  • Printed baby pictures — we sometimes forget to actually print that photos we take but there’s something really special about actually holding hard copies of those early photos.

What Are the Best Baby Keepsake Boxes?

1.  Best Personalized Baby Keepsake Box Overall: Savor Deluxe Baby Keepsake Box


Why  Do We Love It?

There can be no gift better than this for a new Mom, with this keepsake box, you can easily keep your memories intact in a well-organized manner in one place.

If you are looking for the best place to keep all your mementos in one place, this is the right place.

They have been specially curated to give them the looks of a coffee table book.

What Other Moms Say

I love this product. It allows me to personalize everything according to my wish. All the photos, birthday wishes, baby spoon, medical records, and even I have stored the first locks of hair in a special envelope designed for this purpose. I highly recommend this product.


2. Best Baby Tooth Keepsake Box: CampTek Baby Tooth Box and Tooth Holder

Baby Tooth Box and Tooth Holder

Why  Do We Love It?

Available at such an affordable price, this is a great product worth buying. For all the parents who want to preserve their baby’s teeth, this keepsake box is the perfect option.

One of the best things is that it comes with sufficient space for writing the date below each baby tooth.

It is well organized, durable, and resistant to corrosion.

What Other Moms Say

This baby tooth keepsake box is extraordinary for me. I’ll give this to my baby when he grows up. I highly recommend this product. It allows you to store all the baby’s teeth in an organized manner, such an adorable product.


3. Best Wooden Baby Keepsake Box: Dust and Things Personalized Baby Keepsake Box


Why  Do We Love It?

This is one of those top keepsake boxes, which allows you to personalize it according to your needs. This amazing keepsake box comes with printing on it that looks really beautiful.

The box is durable and is of superior quality. With a smooth finish, it is made up of standard pinewood free of knots and blemishes.

What Other Moms Say

This is such a beautiful keepsake box. I must say it met my expectations. I highly recommend it to all those new moms who want to store those precious memories. The size is sufficiently big, so I can store lots of special items from my baby. I am glad that I bought this product. It was worth the price.


4. Best Baby Boy Keepsake Box: Robert Frederick Large Collapsible Memory Storage Box


Why  Do We Love It?

This is the best baby boy keepsake box available online, durable, and well-built. It provides enough amount of space to store photos, mementos, etc. This can be the perfect baby shower gift, and it is an excellent gift for christening.

From the essential baby milestones to those adorable baby toys, you can store those moments in one place and give this keepsake to your child when he or she grows up.

Robert Frederick Large Collapsible Memory Storage Box | Pink My Baby Keepsake Memory Box is the exclusive version designed for baby girls. It looks very adorable and can be assembled easily.

What Other Moms Say

I have been searching for an excellent keepsake, and I finally found this one. I loved this product. It is quite sturdy and large enough to store the different moments, photos, etc. It looks lovely, especially the prints. I highly recommend this.


5. Best Baby Girl Keepsake Box: Baby Milestone Keepsake Storage Box


Why  Do We Love It?

This baby girl keepsake box comes with different conveniences to pull out compartments for various different kinds of moments.

Whether you want to store your baby’s first pair of shoes or your baby’s first tooth, this keepsake box is ideal for you.

If you are looking for a baby shower gift or looking for an adorable and memorable gift for your baby, nothing can be better than this keepsake box.

If you are looking for a keepsake box for boys, then this brand offers a boy’s version, which you can consider buying.

What Other Moms Say

I bought this keepsake for my daughter, it is so cute and looks great. I am pleased with the quality of this product. The best thing is that it is large enough to store many moments and other precious babies items.


What to Look Out for When Picking Your Baby Keepsake Box

  • Size does matter

While choosing a keepsake box for your baby size is crucial. For example, if you wish to keep more significant items like a baby’s bib or your little one’s first shoes, you would need a bigger box. On the other hand, small things like the first broken milk teeth or the first curl would need a tiny box to store the precious memories.

A big A4-sized box resembling a book or first tooth box can fit a 1$ coin; there are many varieties to pick from, as a keepsake box.

  • Durable

The idea of keepsake boxes is for preserving memories. Investing in a durable, long-lasting box can help you keep the invaluable souvenirs of your little ones forever without any damage. Keepsake boxes made of sterling silver and ceramic should be the top pick for beauty and longevity. 

  • The attractive looks

The look of the box is essential. Beautifully carved wooden boxes or classic sterling silver can be a great pick to fit any aesthetics, especially once your little one grows up.

If you want to preserve the memories of your child’s favorite character like Disney’s Winnie the pooh or Minnie mouse can be a fantastic choice. They are super cute, bright, and colorful, all at the same time.  

  • Adding the personal touch

Adding a personal touch with the baby’s name and date of birth is a beautiful idea. There is always a choice of adding name and message; we have a wide variety of options to pick from.

We have found an array of aesthetically designed keepsake boxes for any milestone you want to cherish for your little one. Check out our collection of charming carved wooden pieces or the bright illustrated ceramic keepsake boxes to archive the lovely memories of your baby while they sail into the big world. 

Things to Remember

Kids grow up very fast. We all want to preserve all their growing-up memories. But, do not overload and only keep the little things attached to the best memories. For instance, my little one just loved flipping through her board books when she was young. The most enjoyable time for her was when we read out storybooks to her. Therefore, I wanted to keep a few of her baby books in my keepsake box, which I could gift her when she grew older.

Also, do remember to add the item when they have grown out of it. For example, if they still enjoy playing with their little teddy, you can add it to your memory box once they no longer bother with it.

A keepsake box is also an ideal place to keep the memories connected with their “firsts.” For instance, you can list activities like first words, first steps, or the date and time when they first rolled over; this can be stored in your memory box, which you can use to update their baby book later.


These best baby keepsakes are listed based on customer feedback, features, and pros. Plus, we also mentioned the cons so you can make a wise decision. Also, if you have anything to share, connect with us via the comment section.

>>> Check here to read more posts about the best baby products list.

>>> Check here to read more posts about parenting concerns.

Latest posts by Susan (see all)

Leave a Reply